Using photographs of people from a variety
of cultures, this activity raises questions about universality,
diversity, and human dignity.
Time: |
30 minutes
to 1 hour |
Materials: |
Copies
of the UDHR, complete
or simplified
version
A collection of pictures showing people of many different
cultures, ages, and backgrounds. Especially recommended
are Amnesty International calendars and UDHR 50th
anniversary poster set1.
|
Setting: |
All
ages |
Links: |
An effective
follow-up to Activity 1, Human
Beings/Human Rights. |
Procedure
PART A: Considering a Picture
1. Individually, in pairs or small groups,
choose a picture from the selection.
Study the picture and discuss some of
the following questions.
2. Questions about Universality:
- Why did you choose this picture?
Why do you think the photographer chose this subject?
- What do you find in the picture that
serves as a mirror of your own life, reflecting
something familiar that you can easily recognize?
- What do you find in the picture that
serves as a window onto another culture or way
of living, something that is strange and unfamiliar to
you?
- What do you think is going on here
(e.g., is it a working environment? a religious setting?).
- How is the person(s) feeling?
- In what ways do you think the person(s)
in the picture lives a very different life from you? Has
different values? needs? hopes? expectations of life?
- In what ways do you think the person(s)
in the picture is like you? Shares similar values? hopes?
needs? expectations?
- Is this a complete picture of the
way the person lives? What might be missing?
- Is there any evidence of victimization
in this picture? Of privilege? Of discrimination or privilege
based on class? gender? ethnicity?
- What human rights do you think are
most important to the person(s) in the picture? Do you
think different rights are most important to you?
- Are human rights really universal?
Do you think the person(s) in the picture wants the same
human rights as you do? Do you think the person(s) enjoys
the same human rights as you? Why or why not?
3. Questions about the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights:
- Make a list of all the human rights
you can associate with your picture(s). Include both rights
being exercised and rights denied or violated.
- Match the rights you have listed
with specific articles of the UDHR. Write the number of
the articles on your list. Alternative: Write out the
article(s) illustrated by the picture and display it with
the picture.
- Are most of the rights you have identified
civil and political rights or social, economic, and cultural
rights? See Part V, A Human Rights Glossary. Mark each
as "Civil/Political" or "C/P" and
"Social/Economic/Cultural" or "S/E/C."
- Show your picture(s) to the whole
group and explain the rights you have identified. Ask
for suggestions of other rights participants may observe
in the picture(s).
- After everyone has shown their pictures,
look through the UDHR and consider what articles have
not been identified in any pictures. Are some articles
more difficult to "see" in pictures? In real
life?
4. Questions about Human Dignity:
- Does this picture express human dignity?
How? Does anything in the picture seem to detract from
the human dignity of the people in it? How?
- How would this photograph be different
if it were made a century ago? A hundred years from now?
Do you think that our ideas about human dignity are changing?
If yes, what do you think has brought about this change?
Can you relate that change to our understanding of human
rights?
- Does the picture encourage an appreciation
of human dignity? What does human dignity have to do with
human rights?
- Why do you think the photographer
chose this subject? Why do artists so often choose the
human condition as the subject of their work?
PART B: Grouping the Pictures
1. Place all the pictures together on
the floor or the wall and consider them as a group.
- What common features do all these
pictures share?
- What do these pictures say about
what it is to be human?
- If all of these pictures were taken
in the same society, what conclusions could you draw about
the society? Would you say it was a community where people
had their human rights?
- How would these photographs be different
if conditions changed: (e.g., a civil war? discovery of
oil in the region? achievement of equality for women?
strictly enforced child labor laws? or compulsory primary
education? A livable minimum wage? a viral epidemic for
which no vaccine is available?).
- Based on this collection of pictures,
what statements can you make about human dignity? About
human rights?
2. Try to group certain pictures together
into categories. These might be based on the content, tone,
or human rights involved.
Going Further
1. A Dialogue -- Write
a dialogue between the persons in the picture or between
a person in the picture and you.
2. A Cartoon Draw a cartoon
depicting a story about the people in this picture.
3. Research If possible,
find out where the picture was taken. Find out about that
country or its culture, including its human rights situation2.
4. Create Write a poem
or story or create an artistic expression that captures
an idea or feeling raised by this photograph.
1. For Young Children
- Why did you choose this picture?
- What do you see that is like your
own life, something familiar that you can easily recognize?
- What do you see that is unfamiliar
and different from your own life? Is there anything in
the picture that you dont recognize or understand?
- In what part of the world do you
think this picture was taken?
- How do you think this person is like
you? In what ways is the person not like you?
- What do you think the person(s) in
this picture is doing?
- Make up a story about the person(s)
in this picture.
- How do you think the person(s) in
this picture feels?
- What will the person in this picture
do tonight? Tomorrow morning? What will he or she do that
you do also? What do you think he or she will do differently
or not at all?
- What do you think this person enjoys
doing?
- What do you think this person will
be like in a few years?
- What do you think this person would
like to tell you? To ask you? What would you like to tell
or ask this person?
- Draw a picture that illustrates one
of the questions above.
- Try to copy the picture, matching
colors and shapes as closely as possible.
Source: Human Rights Educators
Network, Amnesty International USA; adapted in part from
Emily Style, National Seed Project
1Calendars
and posters are available from these sources:
a. Publications Office, Amnesty International
USA, 322 8th Avenue, New York, NY 10001. Tel: 212-807-8400.
b. Human Rights USA Resource Center,
310 Fourth Avenue South, Suite 1000, Minneapolis, MN 55415-1012.
Tel: 1-888-HREDUC8.
2The Amnesty Interactive
CD-ROM and Amnesty Internationals annual reports provide
excellent information. They are available from the addresses
above.